Wednesday, 2 November 2016

Chapter 1-3 (revised) Chapter 4(first draft)

Chapter 1.0: Introduction
House is a roof and shelter, and the place where we lay our head at night. Having a roof over the head is a basic need for security and for families to thrive. House provide a feeling of comfort, luxury and identity. (Rebecca Shamasundari, 2016) Housing also contributes significantly to socioeconomic development and the wellbeing of communities. (Economic Planning Unit, 2015) It serves as a shelter and provides a vibrant living environment that will influence and shape human behavior, productivity and development. Quality of the houses including the physical design, interior sizes, facilities provided, security of the surrounding and mental health are important for the tenant. But, the neighborhood, location and the prices are also affecting the quality of the house. The good quality of the house will make the tenant enjoying and upgrading their life quality.

Figure 1. The horizon residences Kuala Lumpur


In Malaysia, people can buy a house base on their needs and ability. In the big cities, for example Kuala Lumpur and Johor Bahru, the cost of houses are not commensurate with the average income of a Malaysian household, especially for those who are categorized under the lower income group. Current state, the apartments or condominiums in Kuala Lumpur cost higher than RM 500,000 and the landed house cost mostly more than RM 1 million. This makes a RM5000 salary workers cannot afford to buy a house in the cities. (KC Lau, 2016) Or they have to use they whole life to pay for the money. For this case, Malaysia government has commitment in providing an adequate, affordable and quality for all the income groups, especially will more focus on development on the affordable housing. The right to housing is a basic need while good quality and affordable housing is a reflection of a high quality of life.

Figure 2. The Technicolor Public Housing. Seen from the train (at Kampong Haji Abdullah Hukum, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia)

So, what is affordable housing? According to Malaysia provision, the price of the affordable home is around RM100,000 to RM400,000. It is open to apply for those who income is between RM2500 to RM7500 per month. For those who income is below RM 3000, they also can buy a house which is below RM 65, 000. (Des, 2014) But they have to apply and wait to for result and arrangement. For those who cannot afford to buy a house, they also have a chance to apply for rent a house. But still need to wait for approval after apply it.

From the news of The Star in May 2015, there are 70,000 residents are on the Kuala Lumpur City Hall (DBKL) waiting list for affordable housing. In some bad cases example, there are people apply to rent a public housing 20 years ago, after 20 years they are still waiting. RM90 will be charge to rent a one-room flat and for three-room flat will be charge RM 124 per month. The low rental has made these units be hunted by the people. (The Star, 2015)

1.1 Aim
This dissertation aims to study and discuss the current situation and issues of affordable housing in Malaysia. As a Malaysian, we should be aware what is going on and understand the current situation and find out the issues, to reach out and help the people in need.
Health issues, safety issues, comfort of life issues will be focus and discuss. And the aim is to study the issues and give the solutions to improve the life quality of the affordable housing resident. The suggestions, including suggestion of planning stage solution, physical solution and sustainable design solution in refining affordable housing will be analyzed in detailed to show the strategy of the Malaysia future affordable housing.

1.2 Methodology
To reach the aims of the dissertation, the issues of affordable housing which affecting the resident will be look into and analyzed deeply. The main issues that will be focused in this dissertation are health issues, safety issues, and comfort and quality of life issues that facing by the resident nowadays. Other than that, a good case study of affordable housing in Germany which project name call Solarsiedlung Am Schlierberg also will be study and to show the possibility that Malaysia can be success too.  To have a more accurate information and deeper understanding to the affordable housing, a site visit to Section 8, Kota Damansara PPR Flat will be conduct and also will carry on a survey to the residents while doing the site visit. To understand what is the reality and the thought of the resident is the most important part in completing this dissertation.





Chapter 2.0: Overview of Malaysia Housing Situation
This chapter is going to discuss about the current housing situation of Malaysia. To clearly explain the situation, different charts will be show and some initiatives will be introduced in detail.

Chapter 2.1 Needs of affordable housing in Malaysia
Why affordable housing in Malaysia is needed? As there are not too many Malaysians can’t afford to buy a house by using their low wages. So for the low-income or middle income people choose to buy a not-that-expensive house or they choose to rent a house. For some are choosing to buy a house at the outskirts of the city. Other than the high price of the affordable housing, the supply of the affordable housing also can’t reach the demand. The population of Malaysian keep increasing. It has increase from 21.3 million in 2000 to 30 million people in 2013 with a growth rate of 1.6% and the birth and death rate have decreased over the years. (KC Lau, 2016)

Chart 1:  Malaysia Population Number

There are many factors that may affect the demand of the housing, including demographic factors (growth in population, number of household increasing and etc), the levels of income, cost of financing. Government policy and personal preferences. In other hand, land cost, government policy, cost of financing and construction cost also will affact the supply of the housing. (Khazanah Research Institute, 2015)

Table 1: This table is showing the percentage of home ownership in Malaysia in 2010. As a development country, it consider as a high number. But in Kuala Lumpur the percentage is only 53.5%. It is also very important to make sure the percentage of home ownership is not decrease.

Chart 2. From the chart above, it shows that the prices of the housing is changing from 2008 to 2014. In 2008, the prices of most of the housing used to be less than RM 250,000. But in 6 year time, the percentage has decreased until 21% and there are 43% of the housing are RM 250,000-RM500,000.

Chart 3. In 2004-2007, the household income is higher than the house prices, but until 2009-2014, the house prices slowly higher than the household income. It shows that the house prices cannot be afford by the low income family.

Chart 4. From the chart above, it shows that the population of Malaysian from 1980-2000 is keep increasing, but the number of housing is still very far away from the demand. In 2016, this situation is still maintain, the supply haven’t reach the demand.

To overcome the over high price housing, Malaysia government had introduce some initiatives to the low-income to middle income people, to help them buy a house. These initiatives is all belongs to government, but different initiatives has their own responsibility. For example, 1Malaysia People’s Housing (PR1MA) launched at 2011. They are in charge of planning, developing, constructing and maintaining high-quality housing with lifestyle concept for the low-income and middle-income household in urban centers throughout the Malaysia. Household income have to be between RM2500 to RM 10,000. The price of the housing is between Rm150,000 to RM400,000. Another initiative is Rent-to-Own(RTO) scheme for PR1MA homes. It is a deferred home ownership scheme especially for successfully balloted applicants of PR1MA homes whose loans were rejected by PR1MA’s panel banks. Under this scheme, the applicant can rent the PR1MA home for 10 years before decide to buy it. The applicant have to choose between PR1MA Basic RTO which is rental plus a saving account and PR1MA zero RTO which is only pay for rental. (1 Malaysia, 2016)(For more detail and info please refer to Appendix)

With time, the house prices are rising exponentially and it will become more difficult for the lower and middle income class of Malaysia to afford a home in the future.
Summary of the chapter
From the charts above, it shows that Malaysia current housing situation is a bit hard for the Malaysian to afford a house especially the low-income and middle-income sector. The supply is not reach the demand, the price of housing keep increasing during years. Other than that, the population is also keep increasing, when the demand of the housing is still lacking. Malaysia government is introducing some initiatives to the society to improve the current situation. Most of the initiatives are focus on low-income and middle-income to make sure they have the ability to get a shelter.



Chapter 3.0: Prices of low-cost housing in Malaysia currently
This chapter is going to discuss the prices of affordable housing in Malaysia. To show the pricing of affordable housing is keep increasing, charts will be add in to show the comparison.

Chapter 3.1 Prices of affordable housing
In chapter 2, the high price of housing had been highlighted. The prices of the housing had become the main reason that to stop the people buying a house. From the research, it shows that Malaysia’s average house pricing is drop at RM 312,205 in year 2015. It has increase 5.41% compare to a year earlier. (Global Property Guide, 2016)

By property type:
Terraced house average prices rose by 5.4% (2.7% inflation-adjusted) to MYR278,223 during the year to 2015.
High-rise residential properties' average price rose by 6% (3.3% inflation-adjusted) y-o-y to RM 296,826.
Detached house average prices rose by 4.1% (1.4% inflation-adjusted) y-o-y to MYR524,260.
Semi-detached house average prices increased 6% (3.3% inflation-adjusted) y-o-y to MYR469,823.


Table 2. Comparison of housing affordability based on annual household median income and median all-house price a cross states in Malaysia, 2014

A new research by think tank Khazanah Research Institute (KRI) had found out the exactly situation of Malaysia housing price. KRI is using median multiples as one of the method to assess the situation and found out that in 2014, Malaysia median house price are 4.4 times the median annual household income. But the global standard for an affordable market should only have a median multiple of 3.0 times.

From the table 1 above, it shows that only 1 state in Malaysia is at the affordable housing market at 3.0 median multiple which is Melaka. Only Melaka is classified as having an “affordable” housing market at 3.0 times mean multiple. And the Terengganu is the state that having the highest median multiple of 5.5 times. The big city, Kuala Lumpur is holding the second high place.

KRI’s report noted that unaffordable housing markets are those which have supplies that either falls far below demand or too inelastic to changes in demand. It is a measure of how affordable the housing market is as a whole, not a measure of what any particular household can afford as that would depend on that household’s circumstances.


Table 3. Number of residential properties launched, by transacted price and house type (2014)

From table 2, it shows that in year 2014, in Kuala Lumpur had no property launched below RM 250,000 to RM 1 million price bracket. Most of the hew-launched properties were between RM500,000 to RM 1 million. This shows that there simply isn’t enough affordable housing being built or the supply unresponsive to the demand. (edGY, 2015)
Why always the affordable housing can’t reach the demand, because the developers are always mistaken that affordable housing project is less profitable when compare to other projects. Based on the case study by KRI, 8990 Holdings in Philippines showed that they earn money from the affordable project by using mass production and pre-cast construction which enabled them to complete the house in a very short period. The price of the house is approximately Rm57,000. (edGY, 2015)

When the prices of affordable housing is not affordable anymore, when the supply cannot fulfill the demand, an action in changing this situation must be taken before everything goes worst. Current housing has their issues, not only prices but is the issues that are affecting the life quality.

Summary of the chapter
Prices of affordable housing is not “affordable” anymore, excluded Melaka. Low-income sector and young generation who working or stay at big city, like Kuala Lumpur are very hard to get a house which categorized under affordable housing.  Even renting a house in Kuala Lumpur is also hard for the fresh graduated student. For some people, they have no choice to choose a better life quality when they just want to get a lower price housing.





Chapter 4.0: Site visit to PPR Flat and the common issues that facing by the resident
To understand more deeply of the affordable housing, PPR flat located at Section 8, Kota Damansara had been visit. So this chapter is going to analyze the issues that the resident had been facing.

Chapter 4.1 Observation of the PPR Flat
This chapter is going to analyze the observation to the PPR Flat.

Chapter 4.1.1 Location of the site

Figure 3: Map to show the location of PPR Flat in Section 8, Kota Damansara

Figure 3 above is showing the location of the PPR Flat in Section 8. The part in yellow highlighted is the PPR flat which has 4 block with 18 floors: Block A, Block B, Block C and Block D. Every block have the same design even the exterior painting. This area is a multi-income group residential area. There are different types of housing, including bungalow, terraced house, condominium and flat in the same area. Other than that, secondary school and commercial areas also can be found nearby (number 2 and 3).


Chapter 4.1.2 Facilities provided

Figure 4: Exterior view of the PPR Flat

Figure 5: Rapid KL buses can be seen outside the PPR Flat.

While walking around the site, there are few Rapid KL buses passed by. So it prove that the public transport is quite convenient. Other than that, the Kota Damansara LRT line is going to operate very soon, and there is a LRT station nearby with a walking distance.
Lacking of parking is the main issues that facing by the resident. During the interview with the resident, most of them are saying that lack of parking is very disturbance. This make them have to park at the road side or double park (figure 6). Another problem had caused which is they had blocked another car and the drive way. They wish to solve the problem by increase the number of parking lot. But for the motorcycle parking area, a shelter has been built. It prevent the motorcycle from raining (Figure 7).


Figure 6: This figure is showing the current parking situation. Double park can be seen.

Figure 7: Parking area of motorcycle.

Basic facilities including football court, children playground and pathway are provided. But the maintenance is very bad, some of the equipment in children playground had broken, but no one took action to repair it. This is very dangerous for the children, children may get hurt. Other than that, the pathway to entering the football court and playground also broken without any fixing. Everyday during evening time, the children will gather at the football court and playground, they had make the place become very lively. They play together and laugh together.


Figure 8: Football Court.


Figure 9: Children playground


Figure 10: Broken pathway

Chapter 4.1.3 Cleanliness of the environment
A dirty environment will affect the health of the resident. When walking towards the playground, litter can be seen everywhere. It might be the resident who staying upstairs throw the rubbish through the window, or the people who using the facilities downstairs simply throw the rubbish when they pass by. But the amount of rubbish is really terrible.


Figure 11: This photo is taken at the site. Rubbish is every way.

Chapter 4.1.4 Interior of the PPR Flat

Figure 12: Two side of the house is too closed.

Figure 12 shows the two opposite houses is facing each other but it is too closed. As it has 18 floors, so it causes the natural sunlight only can enter the higher floor. The lower floor cannot get enough sunlight. It is very dark during days and the ventilation is very bad. When walking around every floor, it is very uncomfortable because of the bad smell. The corridor is very narrow, it only can fit maximum 3 people in 1 row. Some resident is putting their things like bicycle at the narrow corridor. It is not really block the way, but if happen emergency, it may block the people.

Figure 13: Narrow corridor.

The railing of this flat is very unsafety since it caused few cases which is children fall through a gap between the railings. According to The Star Online 2015, a five-year-old children fell to his death from the sixth floor when playing with his brother. This is not the only cases, there are total up 2 same cases which caused little boy death.  

Figure 14: A gap in the railing secured with a wire mesh by residents.

The staircases are provided at the both side of the flat. It didn’t lock, so everyone can enter from the ground to the highest floor expect the rooftop. No one take care the cleanliness of the stairs, rubbish is almost blocking the way and make the staircase very slippery. When doing the survey with the residents, they said that the staircases is very dirty, some people keep throwing the rubbish and sometimes can smell the urine.  So normally they won’t use the staircases.

Figure 15: Rubbish at the staircase area.

 Chapter 4.1.5 Interior of the units

Figure 16: Estimate floor plan of a unit.

Figure 16 is showing the estimate floor plan of a unit. Every unit is having the same space planning which is 3 bedrooms, 1 toilet, 1 shower, living hall, kitchen and balcony. There are 3 windows, one is at the living hall facing outside and the other two is at the kitchen and bedroom 2, which is facing the corridor. So, only one window allow the natural sunlight enter the house. The ventilation of the interior is not very good if the resident didn’t open the window.


Figure 17: Interior of the house. An empty unit.

The balcony of the house is really small. It caused the resident cannot hang their clothes, so they have to choose to hang their wet clothes outside their house or at the corridor. But the corridor also cannot receive enough sunlight, so the wet clothes will increase the humidity of the environment.

Figure 18: Tiny balcony. Photo is taken from outside.

Figure 19: Clothes are hanging at the corridor.

 Chapter 4.1.6 Others
Different than other flat, this flat had security guard at the lobby. And also installed CCTV inside the lifts and some floors. But from the responses of the resident, the safety is still not good. In this few weeks, there are some thief trying to get into their house. This make the residents very worried about their safety.

Figure 20: CCTV can be found inside every lifts.

Summary of the chapter

The living environment of human is very important because it will affect the quality of life. Bad ventilation and lack of natural lighting will caused health issues. Interior space planning, cleanliness of the environment, facilities provided will caused the comfort of life issues. Carelessness of the security guard and the design of the building including railing will caused safety issues. To improve the life quality if the resident, those issues have to solve. 

** Survey still on going, there might have some changes after complete the survey.**

No comments:

Post a Comment